Sunday, March 23, 2025

Top 100+ Albums of All Time (Feb 2025 Edition)

Ladies, gentlemen, and any others who happen to stumble upon this humble blog o' mine - please join me in celebrating a momentous occasion! I finally have posted about my yearly ranking within a month of when it was done! (I have never claimed to be particularly good at getting things done on time, and I expect this to be the exception, not the rule.)

For anyone who hasn't read one of my posts before: First of all, welcome! Each year I re-rank all of my favorite albums of all time and then do a blog post because I'm a nerd about music. My boss likes to tease me that even though I write for multiple entertainment publications, I still do this on the side and probably makes me some kind of masochist lol. ...He might be right. 

Anywho, my goal for the post this year was to keep it much shorter than last year, so I'm going to stop babbling and just get into it!

Methodology & Eligibility

I discussed the way I construct the list as well as which albums are selected in great detail on last year's post. Go check that out for a full breakdown. Seriously, I can guarantee that nearly any question you have about this besides "why is ____ here/not here/so high/so low?" can be found on last year's post.

To sum it up though for you lazy bums: These are albums that are S, A+, or A tier in my opinion. That's why the number is weird and not perfectly round. Things like greatest hits albums are not included, and I need to have listened to the whole thing more than four months ago for it to be eligible. If you have suggestions for things I should check out or that were not included, please suggest kindly! There's a lot more in the aforementioned post, but that should get you most of the way to understanding this list. Speaking of which...

The List

Click here for the full resolution

Takeaways

This year, the total number of albums changed a lot less drastically, with only 16 new entries and 12 dropouts. That's still about 10% of the list, which is maybe a bit higher turnover rate than I'd like ideally, but such is life. It's a lot better than last year's 23 new additions (~15%). Also, for the first time since I started doing this yearly ranking, the top ten albums have remained the same, albeit shuffled around a bit.

Newcomers

I anticipate this being the last time a Rush album is added to the list unless one the remaining seven albums from them suddenly becomes a lot more special to me. I've had a weird hangup in past years about including too much Rush, and this year I finally let myself just add everything I felt deserved it. 

Everything non-Rush is either from my AotY picks for 2024, the second half of my 2023 AotY picks (which were not eligible in 2024), or are just banger albums that I'm finally admitting my love for (Wish You Were Here and Rumors). Not a lot of surprises if you've heard me talk about music at all in the last year.

#51 Magdelena Bay - Imaginal Disk
#55 notsure - stressed
#63 Drusky - Cake & Absynthe
#68 Hello Meteor - SAID GHOSTS
#70 Rush - Moving Pictures
#76 Sego - TANDANG
#90 MMEND - Spectator
#91 Oklou - Galore
#94 Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here
#97 The Moth & The Flame - The Moth & The Flame
#102 Billie Eilish - HIT ME HARD AND SOFT
#103 Fleetwood Mac - Rumors
#111 Rush - Grace Under Pressure
#112 Silly Silky - Silly but, Silky
#124 Thy Slaughter - Soft Rock
#131 Charli XCX - BRAT

Dropouts

Oh man, some of these hurt to drop, but I had to be honest with myself that I don't think they quite earn that A rating anymore. That, or they're technically two albums ranked as one (Rhythm of Youth/Collection) - neither of which would make it without the other - or are embroiled in fake music scandals and have since had some of my favorite songs removed from streaming (Michael). They mostly all sit in the A- category for me, so know that they're still great and totally worth your time.

Automatic Man - Automatic Man
Battle Tapes - Polygon
deadmau5 - while(1<2)
Depeche Mode - Delta Machine
Depeche Mode - Remixes 2: 81-11
Excision - Destroid: The Invasion
KIRARA - Sarah
Men Without Hats - Rhythm of Youth/Collection
Michael Jackson - Michael
Pet Shop Boys - Electric
SHXCXCHCXSHX - Kongestion
Various Artists - Monstercat 028: Uproar

Largest jumps (change of 40 or more)

Gotye - Making Mirrors +44
House of Harm - Vicious Pastimes +41

Only comment here is that Gotye rising so much makes sense. Dropping 50+ spots last year was a huge mistake, and this is just a course correction.

Largest falls (change of 40 or more)

SHXCXCHXCSH - STRGTHS -83
Imagine Dragons - Smoke & Mirrors -75
Battle Tapes - Form EP -70
Strange Talk - Cast Away -70
!!! - Let it Be Blue -50
Cryoshell - Cryoshell -48
The Script - Science & Faith -45
3rd Line Butterfly - Divided By Zero -42
Kim Jung Mi - Now -40

Also don't have a lot to add here. 83 is a truly ridiculous drop for anything, but that's just how things shook out this time! I even relistened to make sure I wasn't being too harsh, and I think I made the right choice. Who knows though? Maybe next year we'll see STRGTHS make a Gotye-level resurgence in response to dropping so much this time around.

Conclusion

And that's the list! Please please please let me know what you think! I love hearing from others about what they think about my rankings as well as what their favorites are. Anything I'm missing? Anything grossly overrated? Anything you're curious why I like it so much or how I discovered it? PLEASE ASK ME ANYTHING I'M BEGGING YOU. Feel free to reach out and let's chat! I also have all the stats from past years saved on an excel sheet and am happy to talk about the data.

Well, that's all I've got! Thanks for reading if you made it this far, and hope you found something cool and new to listen to!

Tuesday, January 21, 2025

Top Albums of the Year: The Dropouts

 


Just a quick and dirty follow-up post for my previous 2024 Albums of the Year post. I mentioned there that the original draft of the post was 34 albums long, which I cut down to 25. I still felt those albums were worth spotlighting in some regard, so I present: The Dropouts.

In alphabetical order, the other nine albums that were in contention for space on the end-of-year list were:

  • Fever by LUCY (2023)
  • How Do You Feel Now? by Joywave (2015)
  • I Contain Flashing Images by No Mana (2024)
  • Nowhere by Friday Pilots Club (2024)
  • Permanent Pleasures by Joywave (2024)
  • Placebo by Betcha (2023)
  • Sky Hundred by Parannoul (2024)
  • Store Brand Talent by Lighten Up, Francis (2024)
  • The Window by Ratboys (2023)
You can listen to the expanded 2024 favorites playlist including these entries here. It's over 24 hours long, so good luck.

Friday, December 27, 2024

Top Albums of 2024 (Album of the Year post)

Grafik desine is my pashun

Welcome to my 2024 favorite albums list!

This has been an incredible year for music! Pop girlies, rap feuds, and country revivals galore. But this blog isn't about mainstream tastes; it's about my own unhinged opinions, and even though I just recently finished the best of 2023 list, I'm already coming at you with 2024.

I'm going to approach this piece a bit different than last year's albums posts (part 1 & part 2). Instead of any rigid word counts, I'm just going to say what I want to without any regard for length, tone, or completeness. Not every single album I loved this year is here either (the original draft of the article was 34 albums and 4500+ words long...). Also, I'm sorting this into a (rough) favorites order, divided into three categories: Honorable MentionsDang Good, and Albums of the Year. As always, this is only albums where my first exposure to them was this past year, with rare exception.

Now, it's pretty clear from looking at this list compared to last year that I am a LOT more involved with new (as in recently released) music than I used to be. Working as a music writer means people are much more interested in hearing about the new/upcoming releases than retreading old ground. There's also a lot more influence from local music because, once again, that's my job. That said, not every album I've reviewed this year is on this list, and in fact, I can name six right off the top of my head I have reviewed that aren't here. Ha, so there!

Ok, enough preamble, let's get into the list! (you can listen to a playlist of these albums here. It's not in order tho, sorry...)

Honorable Mentions

25. LLLL - Paradice (2014)

Gritty, synthy, weirdness squarely in the same space as some of my favorites like Aseul. It feels like it's dripping for some reason, which makes the textures all the more enjoyable. Think proto-hyperpop. Or don't.

Favorite tracks: "Drowned Fish," "Oddness," "You"




24. BT - The Secret Language of Trees (2023)

When this came out last year, lots of folks online were praising it like crazy and saying how much everyone needed to check it out. Well, I was late to the party, but I get the hype now. This is some of the best downtempo and ambient to come out recently, and it helped scratch a lot of the same itch as another album further down this list.

Favorite tracks: "Embers (Producer's Cut), though all the "Producer's Cut" tracks are great


23. Seo Taeji - Ultramania/Seotaiji VI (1999)

Absolute 180 from the 24th spot lol. This is some unabashedly mad Korean nu-metal, which I know every single person reading this list is a huge fan of. I reviewed it as part of KPOPWORLD's throwback series, and fell in love with the intensity here. Gotta be in the right headspace to enjoy it fully, but worth it once you are.

Favorite tracks: "Internet War," "Feel the Soul," "Tank"




22. DELISPICE - Deli Spice (1997)

DELISPICE's debut album kicks off with a track that sounds ripped straight from a '90s-'00s arcade racing game soundtrack, and that tells you most of what to expect here, honestly. It's just fun music for fun times. It's a little Smashing Pumpkins and a little R.E.M. and a dash of U2 at times, but it's all a good time. Also, it's Korean. Check out my full review.

Favorite tracks: "Mask," "chow chow," "Sagittarius," "Corn Flakes"


21. Homephone - Melon Collie (2022)

Super smooth, great feeling bedroom-pop from local Utah band (the first of many). It feels like a late spring sunshiny afternoon. Like, I can't describe why, but it makes me remember my childhood bedroom and the lazy Sunday afternoons of me just lying in my shag carpeted room, daydreaming and building with Lego. It's perfect if you like Jay Som or other artists in that space.

Favorite tracks: "Pistachio," "Dandelion Fields," "Cherry Seeds"



20. Coldplay - Moon Music (2024)

This album surprised me after the mediocre Music of the Spheres. It has some genuinely great tracks and a lot of solid ideas, and it reignited my faith in Coldplay's ability to make decent music. It's not perfect (or even all that good in some aspects - most of Chris's high vocals sound strained instead of relying on his wonderful falsetto, many of the songs don't know how to finish, and even the songs that are reminiscent of previous efforts feel off somehow), but Coldplay's ability to write fun, engaging hooks and smart pop music is on display here. Despite a fair number of misses, this one is more good than bad. (Not too surprising they didn't lean into the marketing for it being Music of the Spheres: Part II though...)

Favorite tracks: "MOON MUSiC," "JUPiTER," "WE PRAY"


19. Dark Dazey - The Dissolving Door (2024)

Think King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard for people who listen to Muse or other more mainstream rock. While perhaps a bit derivative of the group's influences, it's still a lot of fun and is well-executed. If you're going to sound like someone else, the least you can do is do it well, right?

Favorite tracks: "Enemy," "Gong Song," "Dissolving Door," "Junk"




18. Sungazer - Against the Fall of Night (2024)

Another excellent entry from the guys who apparently do know how to count to four and just choose not to. Not quite as good as their debut, Perihelion, but still bangers after bangers.

Favorite tracks: "Whalefall," "Oteldonk," "Hot Saturn," "Paydushko Horo," "Skrontch"


17. AUXO. - AUXILLARY (2023)

One of the best electronic journeys of recent years. Even cooler that it's a local group too. Each of these songs are so unpredictable, yet there's never any point where it veers into random territory. These guys are ones to watch in the upcoming years.

Favorite tracks: "NEVADAA," "DC," "BIKERIDE"




16. Billie Eilish - HIT ME HARD AND SOFT (2024)

So happy this was good after the middling Happier Than Ever. Perfect return to form while still pursuing new avenues for Billie. It's incredibly cohesive, with multiple songs using shared themes and motifs to keep the flow strong and effective. Really hope she keeps up with this sound.

Favorite tracks: "THE GREATEST," "CHIHIRO," "L'AMOUR DE MA VIE," "BITTERSUITE"


15. The Moth & The Flame - The Moth & The Flame (2011)

I could have sworn I'd listened to this one all the way through before this year, but I genuinely can't find any evidence I had. The group played "The Hunt" at Fork Fest as an impromptu encore despite not having anything prepared, and this song was probably singlehandedly the most special live music moment for me this year.

As for the album as a whole: Good soup. Very moody soup.

Favorite tracks: "The Hunt," "Lullaby II," "Dreamer," "&"



14. Red Velvet - Chill Kill (2024)

Red Velvet is just kinda the best. Read my thoughts for KPOPWORLD. Spoiler alert: it's a beautifully vocal-driven bop of an album. Not perfect, but good enough to attract the attention of a few of my friends who don't even like K-pop.

Favorite tracks: "Bulldozer," "One Kiss," "Nightmare"



14. miicah - FATAMORGANA (2024)

It feels criminal to put this so far down, but truth is, I just haven't had enough time with this album for it to seep into my subconscious as much as the others. It's incredibly well-written and well-produced; it's just the newest thing on this entire list. If you like vibey indie rock, this is 100% an album you need to check out. It's got so much to like.

(Side note: Shoutout to Joe for getting me this one on vinyl for Christmas and getting the band to sign it. Really neat!)

Favorite tracks: "INDECEMBER/YOUR BEST," "MERCHANTS," "POiiSON," "SAY ii AM," "FATAMORGANA"


Dang Good

12. SHXCXCHCXSH - DO EP (2024)

It's no secret I love the unpronounceable Swedish industrial/techno group, and their first 2024 release is some of their most generally accessible work ever. Now, that's not exactly saying much, and I don't expect this to be a new club classic, but if newer fans were looking for something a little less esoteric and harsh, DO is absolutely the right move.

The four-song EP is built around a shared vocal sample, distorted and chopped up in slightly different ways — sometimes to the point of complete abstraction. The EP is surprisingly full for only having four tracks, and the sound design is really neat. Also, bonus points for one of the best vinyl releases this year; my copy sounds INCREDIBLE.

Favorite tracks: "DO 2," "DO 3," "DO 1"


11. Oklou - Galore (2020)

In a year where my listening taste was dominated by girlpop and ambient lounge chill, it's really not that surprising that Oklou (the middle ground) found her way onto my playlists. I've been a fan of "another night" for a while now, and I kept meaning to check out more of her stuff. Well one day, it came on again, and I finally said that I was going to do what I'd been putting off.

The sparse, vocal and synth-focused tracks have an eerie, yet natural quality to them, like exploring the North American woods as the sun sets on a late summer day. It's equal parts haunting and soothing, and I can't wrap my head around how she makes it sound like that. Beautiful.

Favorite tracks: "another night," "galore," "I didn't give up on you," "god's chariots"


10. Hoppy - Little While (2024)

Like I said in my review, I can't say a single bad thing about Little While. Mostly because how could you get upset at something so dang smooth and enjoyable? I've never had a significant other hold me and run their hands through my hair as we watch a winter storm set in and just enjoy the warmth we share on the couch in our log cabin retreat, but I have to imagine this is what that feels like. I do wish it was longer though. I think my roommates got annoyed by me playing it on repeat lol.

Favorite tracks: "The Casio," "2:11," "Garage Sketch," "Still Breathing"


9. Bully - Lucky For You (2023)

I got into the Chicago group Ratboys after Mike the Snare's deep discog dive video on them. While I was in that space, Spotify had some interesting radios for me, which included a lot of other cool artists. But one stood out above the rest. One was angrier, more annoyed, more brash and unapologetic, and more willing to speak their mind than the others. By the end of the day on that radio, I had nearly every song from Lucky For You liked, so I figured the rest was worth a shot. Spoiler alert, it was.

Bully has that sort of female-fronted rock sound that feels reminiscent of the 2000s but also carries a lot more earnestness than most of the radio rock of that time. Her voice isn't the most polished thing you've ever heard, and that's part of why it sounds so good. This is someone speaking their mind fully and authentically. It's perfect road trip music, jam in your room music, or just take a break from the world and let yourself sulk a bit music. It's bad feelings but a good time and vice versa. It's passion and energy and all the great stuff you expect from rock blended together. Even if you disagree with her views on "All This Noise," you can't deny the fire and vigor here are compelling.

The best part is that in a time where TikTok has really sunk its teeth into the modern rock sound, this album is devoid of all of that trend-chasing, song-of-the-summer bullcrap. It's just rock for rock's sake (For the record, I don't hate new rock just because the younger generation likes it blah blah blah. I hate it because so many great bands have relented to give the internet copies of whatever everyone else is doing.)

I still love Ratboys and respect the heck out of their music. But in the end, they were merely a steppingstone to a different album that resonated on another level me. Seriously, this album kicks glutes.

Favorite tracks: "Days Move Slow," "Change Your Mind," "All This Noise," "Lose You," "All I Do"


8. Silly Silky - Silly but, Silky (2024)

Silly Silky is far from a 'new' artist, but she might be my pick for best emerging artist of 2024. This mixtape is a behemoth of excellence. From jazzy horn textures to smooth lo-fi electronics, this album has so many mixed-up styles. It's like a mix between Magdalena Bay (who, spoiler, we'll see pop up later on) and Moonchild. The only complaint I have is that this mixtape is LONG. You really feel the full 1-hour runtime.

In isolation though, almost every single one of these 20 songs are better than 90% of what's being released right now. Also, her November EP Debut was also excellent. Seriously, this girl doesn't miss. Go read my review (scroll down to page #006) if you want more of what makes this album great and be sure to remember that you heard it here first when Silly Silky goes nuclear popular.

Favorite tracks: "Cynical," "4D," "Band-Aid," "BB New Attitude," "Happy Accident"


7. MMEND - Spectator (2019)

Another one I've already reviewed and once again, I don't really have much to add. It's just excellent. One fun story though: After the review went live, Mason Winter of MMEND actually came and chatted with me about my thoughts and what I had mentioned in the review. (His studio space is right next to the Provo Music Magazine office, so I see him almost daily now.) The thing that stood out to him was my comment on the album order feeling wrong. It's been five years since they put Specator out, and while he still has a lot of the same connection to the music as he did when he wrote it, there's also a sense of distance now that he can appreciate it differently and judge it based on what it is, not what he expected it to be.

Anywho, we worked together and made an alternate track listing, and I think it's better! The only thing we can't get right is "Warm Hands, Cold Heart" and "Cover My Eyes." Musically they should go in that order, but thematically they fit better swapped. Not super important though. Give it a listen in the new order and let me know what you think.

Favorite tracks: "Slow Down," "Cover My Eyes," "Too Close for Comfort," "Don't Think," "Nothing That Doesn't Happen Daily," Spectator"


6. Charli xcx - BRAT / brat and it's completely different but also still brat (2024)

Ok, I know that not putting Charli in the AotY category, especially as a long-time listener, is a bit controversial, but it's the most brat thing I could do, right?

Seriously though, this album is fantastic. It treads the line of being vapid and brainless fun while holding down a strong undercurrent of deadly seriousness and deeply personal soul-bearing. It's incredible to listen to this album over and over again and peel away layer after layer. The lyrics are great, the production is immaculate - there is truly so much to love here. That said, I don't think this unseats How I'm Feeling Now and Pop 2 as my favorite projects from Charli.

Most of this review was written before the remix album brat and it's completely different but also still brat came out, and hot DANG was that the heat I was missing from the base album. She managed to completely upturn the expectations of what a remix album can be or do while building on the legacy of those tracks. These songs are transformed into everything from gems to hot garbage, and tracks like the "So I" remix elevate and expand the experience of the original album. (Let's be real here too, we all love hot garbage anyway, don't we?)

While I think you probably could create a 'super album' definitive version from mixing the tracklists of the original and the remix versions, a lot of the emotional umph in the remixes comes from the context of the originals. However, the double album is frankly too long. There's a happy middle ground; I'm just not sure what it looks like. Still a banger and a half though, and who am I to convince the world that this isn't perfect? Just go listen already if you haven't. And if you haven't, what did you even do with your summer??

Favorite tracks: "Girl, so confusing" (the version with Lorde might be the best thing Charli xcx has ever released), "365," "Sympathy is a knife," "So I featuring a.g. cook," "Von dutch," "Mean girls"


5. ARTMS - <Dall> (2024)

This album annoys me, but I still love it. I won't dwell on it here too much because I have an entire review where this is the thesis (scroll down to page #006), but <Dall> was almost the most innovative, boundary-breaking release for K-pop ever. To quote myself, "[the intro track] 'url' is as magnificent as it disappointing, and I think that's a good representation of <Dall> as a whole."

Half the album are these incredible, experimental, lush tracks, and the other half is the same generic girl group pop you've heard a thousand times. It's so good when it's good, but otherwise it's just boring. If it was more consistent, this would likely have been my single album of the year. Instead, it's fine. Just fine. That said, the music videos for this cycle are bonkers. (Go read my review for more details on all of this.)

Favorite Tracks: "Butterfly Effect," "Virtual Angel," "Birth," "url," "The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy"

Albums of the Year

These are my picks for best albums of 2024. As such, albums in this section all collectively share the title for AotY for me. They are organized by the order I'd put them in if gun-to-my-head I was forced to pick an order right now as I'm writing this, but this section is very fluid and interchangeable.

4. Sego - TANDANG (2024)

Most years, an album this spectacular would easily be my Album of the Year, but 2024 has punched well above its weight, so here it is just a touch further down.

Man, I really don't have more to say about this album than what I've already said. It's good! It's artsy! It's so much freaking fun. The whole thing is finally on streaming now too, so you don't even have an excuse not to go listen to it! Buy a vinyl too! Just have fun for pete's sake.

Favorite tracks: "COWBOYS AND HINDIANS," "SURRENDER," "MOM," "OH NO," "MALIBU MARY," "TANDANG"



3. Hello Meteor - SAID GHOSTS (2024)

While I don't think this is my favorite album of the year, it might be the one that best represents the first half of my year. You see, I've gotten pretty into vaporwave (again) and the sort of nostalgic chillsynth sounds of The Weather Channel and so on. It just hits, idk. Maybe it's because we didn't get a new ATTLAS album this year and I'm using this as a substitute, but there's something extremely enjoyable about the relaxing, refreshing, yet invigorating tones of Hello Meteor. (Honestly, I hadn't put that ATTLAS theory together until just now as I was writing it, but it makes a lot of sense.)

Beyond the great vibes and lush sonic soundscape, SAID GHOSTS also tells a compelling sci-fi story of space travel and the final approach to a new planet. There's a significant amount of Hello Meteor's discography dedicated to the Jaladri saga, and this one sheds a new light on an underrated aspect of that story. The whole time, robotic voices announce new protocol and narrate the actions of the automated spacecraft, and the first few times you listen, the effect is incredibly immersive. I felt like a traveler being woken from a deep cryosleep, slightly disoriented yet knowing I was taken care of. Lesser albums would beat you over the head with this motif, but SAID GHOSTS only touches on it here and there — just enough to keep it in the back of your head.

Hello Meteor has released five albums this year, and this is the best of the group. It's got a lot of the same strengths as last year's Traditional Dreams For January but builds into a new and very pleasurable space. It touches a bit on the sonic landscape that's made the tracks from the Community Broadcasting series so compelling, and there's a bit of dirt and breakbeat mixed in there too. Personally, I think this is Hello Meteor's best work yet overall, if for no other reason than the experience is so incredibly unified and cohesive yet provides ample variety to prevent the journey from getting stale.

Favorite tracks: "Lambertian," "Egression Protocol," "Nightly Review," "Geopolymers," "Graphite as a Color"


2. Drusky - Cake & Absinthe (2024)

I told the world I'd stop talking about how good Drusky is when it stopped being true, and I'm still here yapping. Seriously, they deserve WAYYYYY more attention than they're getting, and I don't just say that because I run a local music magazine and have any obligation to say that about every band I review. No, Drusky is the real deal.

It's (clearly) hard for me to pick an album of the year, and these top two albums are constantly flipping back and forth. Cake & Absinthe captures so much of what's so real about life: the greats, the not-so-greats, and the pretty dang bads. The mixing and arrangement are so good, and I wish that I could effectively capture the way my heart just shattered the first time I truly understood "Wasted." I've already written a massive paragraph about it, and I don't think I need to do more, but I could. That's the thing - it's so good that I could.

Since writing my review on the album, I've come around a bit "Valentine's Day" and now see a lot of the strengths of the song. However, I still think those strengths are crowded out when it's smushed in a run of five songs that include four of Drusky's best ever. I don't know how to fix it, but maybe it's time to try an alternate tracklisting... As always, go read my review for my full thoughts.

Favorite tracks: "Wasted," "Dead Dog," "Absinthe makes the heart grow fonder," "Big Halftime Show," "Religistitious," "Soap"


1. Magdalena Bay - Imaginal Disk (2024)

Magdelena Bay hits the sweet spot in my music taste of being both totally basic and totally weird at the same time. Like, in me there are two wolves, and they're both happy when I listen to Magdelena Bay. Their music is paradoxically massive and almost intimidatingly intimate at the same time, echoing the same kind of hyperreality and post-post irony that hyperpop was built on. There's a deep level of sincerity here, even in the most banal and basic of sounds. The mixture of production styles, vocal techniques, and throwing genre just completely out the window makes for one incredibly enjoyable ride. It's lush; it's flowy; it's the full package. Even now, months after release, I'm constantly finding new things to love about this album.

I will say, the first time I listened to Imaginal Disk, I found it to be a bit long, or at least paced like it had multiple endings. Since then, I've listened over and over (and over) again. I find it's paced more like a chapter book, with each section having a resting point before the next one. And we hear themes being borrowed from one track to the next, which adds a cool level of consistency and cohesion to the rough storyline of self-discovery and metamorphosis. If nothing else, it's full of bangers that will worm their way into your ears and make you a bit silly. (That's a good thing in case it wasn't clear.)

It's weird because while this album is so dang good, it's the only one in the AotY section I like less than something the artist has previously released. However, when your competition is 2021's Mercurial World, you're already fighting an uphill battle. (It's also so dang good.) These guys are blowing up, for very good reason. I'm bummed up I missed out on the true ground floor with these guys, but stoked I got in relatively early nonetheless. Incredible. Simply incredible.

My only regret with this band is that I didn't get tickets to see them when they came through town a few years back. They didn't come to Utah this tour, and if they ever do again, I imagine tickets are going to be much more expensive because this album has boosted their popularity a ton. :( Lol jk just days before posting this they announced a new tour, and they're coming to Utah again! Already have my tickets. :)

Favorite tracks: "Death & Romance," "Killing Time," "That's My Floor," "The Ballad of Matt & Mica," "Tunnel Vision," "Fear, Sex"

Conclusion

And that's the list! Thanks to anyone who made it this far! I started working on this back in September to make sure I could have it done by the end of the year, and for the first time maybe ever, I finally reached a self-imposed deadline. Let me know what your favorite albums from this year were, and please please please tell me if you decide to check out anything based on my recommendation and whether or not you enjoyed it. One of my favorite things is hearing what people think of my suggestions, so even if you hated it, I want to know.

That's all for me for now! Idk when the next post is coming - maybe March or so if I end up doing my monthly ranking in February like normal. Until then, happiest of holidays, merriest of Christmases, safest of travels, and may your wireless headphones always be charged!

Sunday, November 24, 2024

Top 100+ Albums (Feb. 2024 edition)

Full disclosure before you read; this was supposed to come out nine months ago, and 2024 has been a massive year for music, none of which will be represented in the slightest by the list you're about to see. But hey, it's not like 2023's list didn't come out until months after it was made too... heh.... (look, we've all got bad habits...)

Disclaimer aside, this year's list was a lot of fun to put together (as it always is). This post is going to explain some of my methodology in composing the rankings, show off the new list, introduce (briefly) the new albums, and talk about some of the biggest takeaways and key changes.

Methodology

I briefly explained this before, but this list is not about me ranking the best albums ever for everyone; I am very very open about the fact that this is my list. I don't think this is a bad list, and I would totally vouch for (nearly) every album here's inclusion on a best of all-time list, but I know that these aren't the best albums ever for all of humanity. I have simply not had the time to listen to everything. So instead of complaining "UGH, why isn't _____ on here? Do you even LIKE music?", please just leave me your suggestions for other albums I should check out!

Also, I've had a few people suggest I make the list cap out at a specific number (50, 100, 200, etc). I don't really care for that idea because then something I love and feel strongly about won't be here. Instead of ranking my top x albums, I prefer to rank all the albums I feel are A tier or higher. This means everything here would rank as an S, A+ or A in a tier list. (If you have no idea what I'm talking about, read up on this system here.) This means that I get to include every album that I want to, but I still have to make hard decisions and can't include every album I like. It also means the list sometimes is a weird length, like this year it came out to 160. (If you don't like it, just think of it as top 150 with 10 honorable mentions.)

This year, the process I used (which I will likely use again) was that in the weeks leading up to the list build, I listened to all the albums that I felt were on the cusp (new or otherwise) as well as any of the albums already on the list that I felt needed a re-listen. Then, I gave all the albums a random number, randomly selected them one by one, and compared them to the albums previously chosen this way. It's a bit tedious, but being able to compare them one by one directly instead of guessing their placement is way better.

I didn't want this to be influenced by one particular mood on one day, so once all the albums were in, I let it sit. I took a week or so to see how I felt and made some adjustments here and there. After some swaps and extra time to think, I was ready to call it done. Then everything went into a spreadsheet so I could see all the nerdy stats because I'm a nerd.

Album eligibility

To be eligible for this list, the criteria that I arbitrarily set were as follows:

  • I must have listened to the entire album at least once, more than once is preferred
  • It must have been intended for straight-through listening. So no greatest hits albums or compilations (with rare exception)
    • Live albums are also (with rare exception) excluded, as they tend to serve similar functions as greatest hit compilations
    • This means movie scores are eligible, although many soundtracks might not be
  • My first exposure to the album as a whole must be from over four months ago (to prevent recency bias), no exceptions
  • Deluxe editions, re-releases, and so forth are valid, but only one version of an album can be included (I haven't run into any exceptions with this yet, but I imagine there might be one eventually)
Obviously, this is very subjective criteria (especially the exceptions), but it's also my list, so I can do what I want.

The list

Highlights

This year saw the first time I've ever dropped an album from the list, ensuring that while it does keep getting longer, the list probably (hopefully) won't grow exponentially. 

Newcomers

# 25 No Such Animal - The Entertainer
#31 The Avalanches - We Will Always Love You
#44 ADOY - VIVID
#67 Rush - Presto
#69 APNEA - ANA-043
#72 Rush - Roll the Bones
#75 Coldplay - Parachutes
#83 Sungazer - Perihelion
#90 deadmau5 - Random Album Title
#92 Michael Jackson - Thriller
#94 Health Care - Totality
#104 Owl City - Of June
#106 King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard - PetroDragonic Apocalypse: or...
#114 The Killers - Pressure Machine
#117 Better Corners - Modern Dance Gold Vol. 1
#124 my dead girlfriend - Hades
#130 Matt Lange - Isolated
#134 Olivia Rodrigo - SOUR
#142 A.G. Cook - 7G
#146 House of Harm - Vicious Pastimes
#149 Eric Whitacre - Whitacre: Choral Works Vol. 1
#150 KIRARA - Sarah
#159 Depeche Mode - Remixes 2: 81-11

The newcomers are a mostly split between new stuff I loved in 2023 and albums that should have been on the list all along but were excluded for some reason. It's simple as that.

Dropouts

Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness - Andrew McMahon in the Wilderness
Brian Eno/David Byrne - My Life in the Bush of Ghosts [Bonus Tracks]
deadmau5 - Strobe (Remixes)
Eric Whitacre - Light & Gold
Jazz Spastiks - Camera of Sound
Jon Hopkins - Insides
Nothing But Thieves - Nothing But Thieves
SHXCXCHCXSH - OUFOUFOF
The Cure - The Head on the Door

These albums were dropped for one of a few reasons. Some didn't actually fit the criteria because I hadn't even listened the whole way through before to tell the truth. Once I did, I deemed them still great, just more in the A- range. Others originally made it on the list through one or two really strong tracks or a sense of obligation that I needed to include something by that artist because of how much of an influence they've been on me. The ones I'll call out specifically are: Strobe (Remixes), which is a great remix pack, is still worth listening to, but honestly, the ATTLAS remix was pulling all the weight there; and Light and Gold, which was there partly to represent my love for Eric Whitacre on here, but I realized this was the wrong album to do that. The BYU Singers album captures so much more of what I enjoy about his work, and the performances and song selection are, generally speaking, better.

Largest jumps

WALK THE MOON - Walk the Moon +53
Magdalena Bay - Mercurial World +45

Largest falls

Gotye - Making Mirrors -55
mau5trap x Insomiac Records -54
The Killers - Battleborn -52
Moonchild - Little Ghost -48
Muse - Drones -45

Takeaways and conclusion

Now that it's been a few months, I think there are certain placements that I disagree with in hindsight. Gotye falling 55 spots is way too much, for one. There are also a few albums that I have on here that I'm not sure I should have added. I might make a separate category at some point for albums like Dark Side of the Moon and Thriller that are objectively incredible and important albums but are not my personal favorites. I've also thought about expanding this list to include the A- albums, but I honestly think that would double the size of the ranking, so that's off the table probably forever.

In the future, I hope to get this list out within a month of the new rankings, as the fact I don't agree with this ranking as I post it is kind of silly. That said, I felt like this was an important one to put out anyway so I can keep the habit going and so that 2025's list doesn't balloon into a ridiculously sized overblown writeup (like this one).

So that's that list! Let me know your thoughts! I'm always more than happy to give recommendations, and I do enjoy receiving them as well. Happy rest of your 2024! You should be seeing my year-end favorite albums list here soon, as well as the newest installment of this list in a few months. That is, unless I get distracted and sidetracked again...

Sunday, October 13, 2024

Favorite albums of 2023 (part 2)

Over a year ago, I wrote a list of my favorite albums I'd discovered in 2023 and alluded to a likely second part coming later. Well, later doesn't have a expiration date, so here's the long-awaited-by-exactly-nobody Part 2 to that post!

Because this is coming so dang late, I'm going to be abbreviating the reviews a bit. After all, can't let perfect be the enemy of done, right? I'm completely reworking my review/list format in another upcoming post, but until then, you're getting this weird mishmash of styles and voices. Just because it's less polished doesn't mean the music is any less good though, so go check it out.


No Such Animal - The Entertainer (2023)

I. Love. This. Album. In my earlier post, I alluded to an upcoming album that I was anticipating taking the cake for 2023, and this was that foretold album. I'm good friends with No Such Animal, and actually got to listen to The Entertainer almost a month early, so there's definitely a lot of personal bias or whatever here from hearing the early demo versions and contributing ideas, but all of these songs hold a very special spot in my heart. (I'm even in the music video for "New American Cyborg" lol.) I did a full review for Provo Music Magazine, which you can read here. That's got most of my thoughts, so I won't rehash it all here.

The only thing I will add is that in the almost year since its release, The Entertainer has absolutely held up. This wasn't some flash-in-the-pan craze that entranced me with whistles and sparkles for a short while before the honeymoon halo effect wore off; this is the real deal. It's incredibly well organized and paced, and when I first showed it to one of my best friends, he legitimately started crying when it finished. He was so moved and touched once it was over that he wept. Yeah, this is more than just a good album from a fun local rock group; this is genuinely some of the best music I've heard, period.

Favorite tracks: On My Own, The Entertainer, Mr Spaceman, New American Cyborg, Corrode, Bones, Out There

Spotify | YouTube


Health Care - Totality (2023)

Totality is another case of a local rock band putting out an absolute banger of an album that deserves way more attention and respect than it has gotten. I also wrote about this one for PMM, but one thing I had to cut for length is how good the production is. The whole album is incredibly mixed; the jangle of the acoustic guitar stands out from the wash of the electric guitar, and each instrument holds its own space wonderfully. So much music is compressed to flip, and it loses so much of the personality in the composition. Rock production and mixing makes a huge difference, and this album proves that.

Favorite tracks: In the Eyes of All, Incomplete, Home Free, Totality, What a Shame

Spotify | YouTube


notsure - stressed (2023)

I've been following notsure for several years and was really excited to see he was releasing a full album. His glitchy, expressive textures are both incredibly detailed and gloriously exuberant. I've used his track "Dialed In" to introduce friends to the intensely packed sound of glitch music, and even people who don't enjoy electronic music or other more noise-focused genres have commented on how unique and enjoyable it is.

This album sees notsure take a bit of a smoother approach, though it's still definitely him. This album is gorgeous and emotional, with tracks that feel like they're straight out of a 2010s movie score. The amount of ear candy on this album is fantastic too. Admittedly I don't actually buy as much music nowadays as I wish I did unless it's in physical formats, but this one was so good I just had to get it. Like The Entertainer, stressed has held up incredibly well since its release a year ago. It sounds just as fresh and deep as it did day one. Admittedly, I do have a decent amount of bias here too, as I watched notsure assemble many of these tracks live on Twitch and managed to snag a ticket to the digital listening party on Bandcamp. However, this album holds the kind of appeal that perfectly straddles the line between unusual/outside of the everyday listening habits of most people. and still being absolutely something that most people would find enjoyable. Seriously, go show notsure some love.

Favorite tracks: "errchk," "still here, with you," "re::wrkd," stressed," "run condition"

Spotify | YouTube

Thy Slaughter - Soft Rock (2023)

The end of an era is always such a bittersweet moment, and Soft Rock was the last hurrah for label and collective PC Music. I was late to the party, only getting into PC Music about two or three years ago, but this sort of sickly-sweet, semi-ironic, kitchy electronic music is the kind of thing I know high school me would have been horrified to know that I'm really really into now. The whole scene drips with that sort of aggressive earnestness that is hard not to at least respect. I'm no expert on the scene, so I'll quit trying to describe it before I mess something up too much.

Late last year, it was announced that this would be the final release from the label and would be the first full-length album from A.G. Cook and EASYFUN's collaborative project, Thy Slaughter. And boy, I don't know if I can imagine a more perfect sendoff album. The whole thing glistens with glitchy atmosphere and distorted vocal lines (some of which are contributed by non-credited artists like Charli XCX and Caroline Polachek). It's deep in the trenches of that sort of post-irony that PC Music always held. It's genuine and full of a lot of real heart, but it's also not that deep, man.

The album carries a surprising (though I shouldn't be too surprised given the title) amount of rock influence, which has interestingly seemed to predict several of the more mainstream trends on social media since its release. I say predict and not create, because to me, this was an album that was never meant for massive mainstream attention and success (though it is good enough and palatable to a general audience; even my mom like some of the tracks). No, this album was meant as a love letter to fans, to music, and to the journey of the previous decade. If it succeeded commercially, great. But if not, those who it was made for would still appreciate it. Like many love letters, there is a twinge of sadness and longing in there that really drives home the bittersweet nature of goodbye. Thank you, PC Music, and here's to the next generation of music innovators and explorers.

Favorite tracks: Reign, Sentence, Immortal, Heavy, O Fortuna

Spotify | YouTube

Sego - Sego Sucks (2019)

I used to hate Sego, but this album showed me the err of my ways. It's not the most mind-blowing of albums, but it now holds a special place in my heart because the review I wrote about it for PMM is arguably the reason I have the job I do now. It's also still one of my favorite reviews I've ever written. Go read it.

Favorite tracks: Heart Attack, Neon Me Out, Sucker/Saint, Shame

Spotify | YouTube






Piano Shoegazer - Sisyphus Happy (2023)

We're now getting into a few albums that I have less to say compared to the others. Piano Shoegazer's debut album isn't for everyone, but it offers a lot of new ideas and wild sonic concepts that push the boundaries of what's acceptable as music. Now, I don't mean this as it's just noise; what I mean is that the songs here carry a lot of that same familiarity and comfort as your favorite music would anyway, but there's something wrong, something distorted. It's almost uncomfortable because it's so close to being what you'd expect and hope for, but it's just not quite that. I've previously described the album as the sonic embodiment of a liminal space, and I absolutely still stand by that. It's really cool, but also pretty disconcerting if you aren't ready.

Favorite tracks: Wet Moon, Escape, Oblique Energy, You Don't Want This

Spotify | YouTube

House of Harm - Playground (2023)

Not much to say here, I just really like House of Harm. They're like if all the best new wave, post-punk, and goth rock groups of the 80s and 90s had access to the magic of modern technology and production techniques during their heydays. I know that everyone hates being compared to legendary bands of decades gone by, but anyone who likes moody groups like The Cure, The Smiths, or Depeche Mode should give these guys a listen. I don't like Playground quite as much as their earlier album Vicious Pastimes, but it's still a dang good effort by the group.

Favorite tracks: Roseglass, Place it Back, Endlessly

 Spotify | YouTube


Better Corners - Continuous Miracles vol. 2 (2023)

Less abrasive and more ambient than 2022's Modern Dance Gold, this album is perfect for a cold night in by yourself. It's a bit moody and dark, very contemplative, and full of all the wonderful experimental goodness that defines a Better Corners release. Give it a listen if you've ever felt that profound sense of awe that sometimes comes while standing in a modern art gallery. Seriously, if you've ever experienced that moment where an abstract visual piece hits you like a truck for reasons you can't explain, this is for you. If that sounds like your nightmare, maybe choose something else from this list instead.

Favorite track: Continuous Miracles

Spotify | YouTube


And with that, I can officially say goodbye to 2023 - a year that honestly, kinda sucked for me besides a few bits, and the music was a lot of those good bits. I've had this hanging over my head for over a year now, and it's good to be done. I think what made it hard to finish was not just the job change etc, but also the fact that most of these albums wouldn't be eligible (per my own rules) for my yearly album ranking in February, so I wasn't quite as interested in talking about them anymore. (Speaking of which, one of my next posts will be that updated list! I've already got that post nearly done, so it just depends on when I want to publish it.) Plus, Christmas always throws a wrench in things music-wise, so that probably contributed too.

Once again, even though this isn't the most current list of albums, I still encourage you to read about it and let the winds of discovery take you where they will. And as always, please let me know if you liked any of my recommendations! Hearing that I introduced people to new music they enjoy is one of my favorite things ever.